# ‘Police weren’t overwhelmed by people protesting and marching’ over education and cost of living

https://mins.news/en/item/106471

- France 24, 2026-10-19 14:58 UTC
- Politics
- Original: https://www.france24.com/en/video/20261019-police-weren-t-overwhelmed-by-people-protesting-and-marching-about-education-and-cost-of-living

> Andrew Smith says France’s escalating unrest exposes a troubling gap between legitimate public grievances and the government’s increasingly security-focused response. He argues that violence during largely peaceful demonstrations points to serious policing failures, while Emmanuel Macron’s response offers “very little of substance.” Economic insecurity, educational inequality and political paralysis are converging, he says, and repression risks worsening the crisis.

## Related coverage

- [France faces scrutiny of public-order policing after violent protest weekend](https://mins.news/en/item/106803) — France 24, 2026-10-19
- [Macron grows increasingly isolated amid unrest across France](https://mins.news/en/item/106616) — euronews, 2026-10-19
- [Ferocious criticism from all sides underscores Macron’s isolation](https://mins.news/en/item/106617) — The Guardian, 2026-10-19
- [‘Police weren’t overwhelmed by people protesting and marching’ over education and cost of living](https://mins.news/en/video/106496) — France 24 English, 2026-10-19